The Presidio Group Exclusively Advised Dreyer & Reinbold on the Sale of Seven Indiana Dealerships to Five Star Automotive Group

ⓘ This article is third-party content and does not represent the views of this site. We make no guarantees regarding its accuracy or completeness.

The Presidio Group LLC (“Presidio”), an independent merchant banking firm focused on mergers and acquisitions, capital raising and investments in the automotive retail and consumer mobility sectors, exclusively advised Dreyer & Reinbold Inc. (“Dreyer & Reinbold”) on the sale of seven dealerships in metro Indianapolis and their related real estate to Five Star Automotive Group (“Five Star”). The transaction included three Indianapolis dealerships — the group’s flagship Dreyer & Reinbold BMW North and Infiniti and Mini stores — plus four dealerships in nearby Greenwood, Ind., representing BMW, Infiniti, Subaru and Volkswagen. The transaction closed Nov. 16.

The sale represents an important transition for the Reinbold family, which has an automotive and motorsports heritage in Indianapolis dating back 100 years.

“Selling a family business with this much history was an important and deeply personal decision, so it was essential to find the right organization to carry these dealerships forward,” said Derek Reinbold. “Five Star is a respected, family-owned organization that shares our commitment to employees, customers, and the communities we serve. Presidio gave us confidence throughout the process, helping my family understand our options, guiding us through each step, and ultimately delivering an outcome that honored what my father and our family built. The process came together more quickly and smoothly than we anticipated, and we are grateful for Presidio’s guidance and support.”

The Reinbold family will retain Dreyer & Reinbold Racing, the Indianapolis-based team that has competed in IndyCar racing, including the Indianapolis 500, for more than 25 years.

For Five Star Automotive Group, the acquisition significantly expands its existing Indiana platform. Five Star entered the state with the purchase of five dealerships in nearby Lafayette in 2021 and had grown to six stores in Central Indiana prior to this transaction. The addition of the Dreyer & Reinbold stores further broadens Five Star’s regional presence and adds several highly regarded franchises to its portfolio.

“Dreyer & Reinbold has built an exceptional reputation over generations, and we have tremendous respect for what the Reinbold family has created,” said Wes Pope, vice president and operating partner of Five Star Automotive Group. “These dealerships are an important addition to our Indiana business and significantly strengthen our presence in the Indianapolis market. The acquisition expands our portfolio with a strong group of franchises and further advances our long-term growth strategy in Central Indiana. We have known and trusted the Presidio team for years, and their market knowledge, industry relationships and disciplined management of the process gave us confidence from the beginning. We appreciate the opportunity they brought forward and the efficient, professional way the transaction came together.”

The Dreyer & Reinbold stores drew significant buyer interest at a time when acquisition demand remains particularly strong for high-quality dealerships representing the most sought-after brands. Dealers consistently rate BMW and Subaru among the most desirable brands to represent, with Subaru ranking No. 4 and BMW No. 6 in Presidio’s Midyear 2026 Dealer Direction Survey.

“Businesses like Dreyer & Reinbold rarely become available, and when they do, there is significant interest from sophisticated buyers,” said George Karolis, president of The Presidio Group. “Our responsibility was to capture the value of an outstanding group of dealerships while respecting what this business meant to the Reinbold family. We were honored that they entrusted Presidio with that responsibility, and our team moved quickly to identify qualified buyers and match this iconic Indianapolis business with a respected family-owned operator committed to the long-term success of these dealerships.”

The transaction illustrated the continuing flight to quality in dealership M&A as buyer selectivity increases. Including the Dreyer & Reinbold stores, Presidio has advised on transactions involving 20 luxury-brand dealerships so far in 2026. The Dreyer & Reinbold Subaru location was the sixth Subaru store in Presidio-advised deals since 2025.

“The dealership M&A market remains highly active, but buyers are increasingly concentrating their capital on the strongest brands, assets and markets,” said Alex Watterson, managing director at The Presidio Group. “The pace and composition of our transactions this year reflect that selectivity, with significant activity involving luxury dealerships and other highly sought-after franchises. We expect those characteristics to continue driving some of the most competitive transactions in the buy-sell market.”

Seller legal counsel was provided by Mallor Grodner Plummer LLP. Buyer legal counsel was provided by Underwood & Roberts, PLLC.

The Presidio Group provided exclusive M&A advisory services to Dreyer & Reinbold Inc. through its wholly owned investment bank, Presidio Merchant Partners LLC.

About Dreyer & Reinbold

Dreyer & Reinbold has served automotive customers in the greater Indianapolis area for more than 53 years. The family-owned dealership group represented BMW, Infiniti, Mini, Subaru and Volkswagen and served customers throughout Indianapolis and surrounding Central Indiana communities, providing new- and used-vehicle sales, vehicle financing, parts, maintenance and repair services. For more information, visit www.dreyerreinbold.com.

About Five Star Automotive Group

Five Star Automotive Group is a family-owned automotive retailer based in Macon, Ga. Established in 1986, the dealership group has grown to more than 30 locations across the South and Midwest representing 19 major automotive brands. Five Star dealerships sell new, used and certified pre-owned vehicles and provide service and parts. For more information, visit www.drivefivestar.com.

About The Presidio Group LLC

The Presidio Group was founded in 1998 with the simple mission to relentlessly put the interests of its clients first. By steadfastly adhering to this philosophy, the firm has earned the trust of clients throughout the United States. During their careers, the professionals at Presidio have collectively completed more than 330 transactions for nearly $23 billion. The Presidio Group, based in Denver and Atlanta, publishes research, industry insights and data reports about the automotive retail landscape. Presidio Merchant Partners LLC is a subsidiary of The Presidio Group LLC and is a member of FINRA and SIPC. For more information on Presidio, visit www.thepresidiogroup.com.

“The dealership M&A market remains highly active, but buyers are increasingly concentrating their capital on the strongest brands, assets and markets.” — Alex Watterson, managing director at The Presidio Group

Contacts

Report this content

If you believe this article contains misleading, harmful, or spam content, please let us know.

Report this article

Recent Quotes

View More
Symbol Price Change (%)
AMZN  255.30
-2.45 (-0.95%)
AAPL  352.05
-0.73 (-0.21%)
AMD  493.57
-10.71 (-2.12%)
BAC  49.37
-0.71 (-1.43%)
GOOG  277.73
-3.53 (-1.26%)
META  617.31
-9.10 (-1.45%)
MSFT  499.60
-18.39 (-3.55%)
NVDA  155.13
-1.01 (-0.65%)
ORCL  114.61
-4.48 (-3.76%)
TSLA  378.75
-0.99 (-0.26%)
Stock Quote API & Stock News API supplied by www.cloudquote.io
Quotes delayed at least 20 minutes.
By accessing this page, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms Of Service.